I’ve decided to pick this film to wrap up my look into Searchlight Pictures. Starting back during the start of the new decade, Disney decided to drop the Fox label on their recent studio acquisitions of 20th Century and for the company in question. Their reason is that they didn’t want any brand confusion with Fox News. Albeit I think it’s a sly way to not associate themselves with the conservative network and have the baggage. With that, this film is I think the next evolution for the studio to embrace a new kind of big budget indies.
1. Bella’s Odd Journey
I think of all the film’s that I’ve covered so far involving the studio, this is by far the strangest and sort of unorthodox film that I’ve seen. I think what made me second guess is that it was a huge swing from Searchlight that I’d assume it was their attempt to imitate A24’s style of films. Just how it looked reminded me of something I watched back in the mid-2010s. While I’ll get to the production, this is a unique film that is at its core about woman’s independence.
Based on the book of the same name by author Alasdair Gray, the film is about Bella Baxter who is a young woman who has been brought back to life via a brain implant. That’s barely scratching the surface with this one, since there’s a lot that goes on with the film. While it’s not that complicated to follow, since we follow Bella as she grows and matures. Although, having the same body but having a brain like a toddler. I’m pretty sure I’ve lost any potential readers due to the strange plot.
It's interesting watching Emma Stone perform in this role. At the time, I mostly associated with her with doing mainstream roles. From Easy A to La La Land, she became the new female lead, especially with winning an Oscar with the latter film. I think with any actor or actress, they have a phase where they want to divert from their mainstream output with something where they want to be artsy. The only example I can think of is Robert Pattinson, from Twilight to appear in a film where there’s multiple copies of himself. I believe that it’s a unique way to diversify their range as far as acting.
Back to what I was talking about. In a way, this is sort of like a unique take on the story of Frankenstein’s monster. Where we see Bella being experimented on and inevitably having independence as a creature created by science. There’s never a moment when she goes on a rampage, but one where we see her slowly gaining enough intellect where she’s defying societal norms. It’s interesting where her intellect and curiosity is mostly derived from her creator Dr. Baxter. To the point where she basically is curious enough to see what the world is like.
Although, when it comes to her curiosity, she attracts some men in her life who only love her to control her. Part of the highlight when it comes to the film is seeing her interact with the different men in her life. Willem Dafoe does a good job with being the Dr. as he’s the father figure to Bella. And speaking of men, Mark Ruffalo just hams it up with his accent as he portrays Duncan. He mostly seduces Bella to be his wife but is mostly vexed by her unorthodox personality. The scene I think represents it is when they’re dancing at a hotel. Bella dances to the music as Duncan joins her
2. Yorgos Lanthimos
To be honest, this is the first movie that I’ve seen of the director. Years prior, I remember seeing ads to one of his movies called The Lobster with Collin Ferrel as the lead. From there, I wasn’t into the weird cinema since my head was stuck with the mainstream stuff and watching assigned films that I had to be discussed in my film classes. With how everything is presented in this film, from the location title cards to the film’s distinctive look, it’s clear that only Lanthimos can pull off the visual aesthetic.
There’s a limit to how weird a director can go to the point where the abstract can be a film’s detriment since it takes away with what’s going in the central story. This isn’t David Lynch with how weird his films are and it’s up to the viewer’s taste. With how Yorgos shows the Victorian era in his own way, I feel that it’s very hyper stylized to the point where one can say it’s gothic but maybe Hyper-Gothic is sufficed. With the costumes and everything about the world gives it’s own sense of weirdness where it’s legible.
3. "Barbie"
It’s surprising that I haven’t dedicated a month where I talk about the copycat films. What those are is when two films have near identical plots but the only thing different about them is the title of the individual movies. The easiest examples is when DreamWorks released Antz and Disney/Pixar released A Bug’s Life, both center on insects as the ant is the main character. What I’m getting at is during 2023, Barbie the movie was everywhere as far as the public consciousness while Poor Things came out near the end of the year.
Both films deal with the main character figuring out who they are as they are exposed to a world that is male dominated and having a figure that tries to win their affection respectively. Having watched both films, since I wanted in on the Barbenheimer craze since I wanted to know what the hub bub was for the Barbie movie. I feel that when you put the film together, it’s clear in my mind that Poor Things is the more ambitious film as far as having the main character gain her own independence.
Mind you, Barbie is a great film in its own regard. Although, I feel that where it falls short is the ham-fisted message that of course lies in with the toy that has been beloved by generations. Now, a movie based on a book and a toy is mostly like this. A book adaptation can go in any direction that the author couldn’t and a film based on a toy can’t quite be progressive and evocative since it’s mostly confined to being a toy. It’s a product where the only real difference it can make is mostly through the dollars that Mattel can conjure up. Maybe someday I’ll talk about Barbie, but when comparing the two. Poor Things is superior when talking about independence.
4. Overall
Poor Things is one of the best films of the 2020s and one of Searchlight’s best film of the decade so far.